• Contact Us|
  • Terms & Conditions|
  • Team Members
  • Products
    • Product Catalog
    • Ductile Iron Pipe
    • Request Product Information
    MJ Mechanical Joint

    View the different joints and sizes we offer for ductile iron pipe.

  • Learning Center
    • Specifications
    • Submittal Sheets
    • Installation Guides
    • Downloadable Tip Sheets
    • Iron Strong Blog
    • Training Opportunities
    • Archived Catalogs
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Videos
    • Pocket Engineer
    DIP Production

    We provide all the necessary product-related information to our customers.

  • Sales & Support
    • Sales Team
    • Distributors
    • Treatment Plant Sales
    • Customer Service
    • Sales Operations
    DIP MJ Joint

    Our sales team strives to exceed customer expectations every day.

  • Corporate Responsibility
    • Code of Conduct
    • Environment
    • Health & Safety
    • Community
    • Awards

    A clear vision from our leaders, places environment, health and safety at the core of our business.

  • About Us
    • Company History
    • Executive Team
    • Locations
    • Associations
    • Contact Us
    McWane Ductile Iron Pipe

    We are a proud and experienced manufacturer of ductile iron pipe products.

  • Communications
    • Publications
    • McWane News Articles
    • Press Releases
    • Media Contacts
    Ductile Iron Pipe

    We strive to keep our team members, customers, and vendors informed of all happenings at the company.

  • Careers
  • Home
  • Learning Center
  • Iron Strong Blog
  • Can Using Ductile Iron Pipe In Your Water System Save You Money On Your Electric Bill?
Back to Blog

Can Using Ductile Iron Pipe In Your Water System Save You Money On Your Electric Bill?

By Jon Melloan   11/19/2018  In Products Technical

Water and Wastewater treatment plants typically are the largest energy consumers for municipalities.  They account for 30 to 40% of total energy consumption. (Source: US EPA “Energy Efficiency for Water Utilities”, April 24, 2017)

Since water and sewer infrastructure plays such a significant role in the total energy consumption of municipalities, more emphasis should be placed on energy savings when selecting pipe materials. 

All too often, utilities are unaware of the potentially significant energy savings over the life cycle of the pipe material.   Many do not do the proper flow rate comparisons and instead focus solely on the price per foot on the bid form.  They ultimately pay more in the long run.

When it comes to the INSIDE DIAMETER of water pipelines, bigger is better when a utility looks at the monthly electric bills that are paid for pumping water throughout the system. Why is this the case?

Having trouble viewing on YouTube? Click here to view on Wistia.

4 Factors That Affect Water Resistance Through a Pipeline

When water flows through a pipeline, there are four factors that affect the resistance to that flow—

1) The velocity of the water flow

2) The roughness of the interior surface of the pipe

3) The length of the pipeline and

4) The INTERNAL DIAMETER of the pipe.

When all of these variables are identified, they can be placed into the well known Hazen-Williams Formula to determine the head loss that is occurring in the pipeline. Because the value of the inside diameter appears in the denominator of the Hazen-Williams formula, the larger the inside diameter, the smaller the head loss. 

So what is the practical side of this evaluation to the water utility?

In order to finally get water to customers at adequate pressure, head losses must be overcome by using pumps to apply energy. This energy is a cost to the water utility in the form of their electric bill. The less energy that must be applied, the lower the electric bill to the utility.

These annual cost savings can easily be calculated using the head loss value and inserting that value into a pumping cost equation such as that used in the University of Michigan Study “A Framework to Evaluate the Life Cycle Costs and Environmental Impacts of Water Pipelines.” (ASCE Conference Proceedings, Pipelines 2016)  It can even be further extended by evaluating pumping cost savings over many years using a present worth approach.

All of these calculations can be conveniently performed on the Energy Savings calculator on the McWane Pocket Engineer where inside diameters of different pipeline materials are evaluated against that of Ductile Iron.

Due to its larger inside diameter, ductile iron outperforms other competing pipe material when it comes to flow rates in the pipeline.

There's so much space in here

Calculating Head Loss

I mentioned earlier the roughness on the interior surface of the pipe being a factor in calculating head loss. This is commonly known as the “C” factor of the pipe.

It should be noted that although other pipe materials have higher “C” factors, thus a smoother inside surface, this component doesn’t affect pipeline flows nearly to the degree as increased inside diameter.

It has also been found by research that the “C” factor of ductile iron pipe remains consistent even throughout many years of service.

Now let’s look at an example wherein a utility is going to install a mile of 8” pipeline in a subdivision, and the materials being considered are Ductile Iron Pipe and PVC.

In determining the energy costs to the utility of each respective material, the project model as noted in the information below has been established:

  • 8” DI Pipe vs. 8” PVC Pipe
  • Pipeline Length: 5,280 ft.
  • C Factor: 140
  • Flow Rate: 695 GPM ( Tech Park Demand)
  • Unit Power Cost: 0.06 $/kWh
  • Pump Rate: 24 Hr/Day
  • Pump Efficiency: 70%
  • Design Life: 100 Years
  • Rate of Return: 5%
  • Inflation Rate: 4%

By going through the steps of first determining the respective head loss that must be overcome in each pipeline, then converting that into pumping costs the utility will incur based on the assumptions listed, one finds that using ductile iron pipe will result in a cost savings to the utility of over $80,000 during the  100 year estimated service life of the ductile iron pipe. The reason for this cost savings to the utility is that 8” Ductile Iron Pipe ( Class 350) has a  9.76% larger inside diameter than does 8” PVC pipe (DR-14).

Bundle of Ductile Iron Pipe

Calculating Savings

Cost savings to the water utility can even further be enhanced when looking at larger size pipelines that typically carry larger flows to the system.

  • Length of pipe:                            30,000 ft.              
  • Flow rates:                                   6,000 gpm
  • Unit power cost:                          $0.10/kwh
  • Pump efficiency:                          70%
  • Pump rate:                                   24 hrs/day
  • Design life:                                   100 years
  • Rate of return:                             5%
  • Inflation rate of power cost:       3%
Ductile Iron Pipe vs HDPE Internal Diameter
Ductile Iron Pipe vs PVC Internal Diameter

Using the same approach in calculating the cost savings to the utility when considering a 24” pipeline under the assumptions above, you find that respectively the use of Ductile Iron Pipe will result in a $1,213,307 present worth savings over PVC pipe, a $672,178 present worth savings over steel & concrete pipe, and a $3,208,741 present worth savings over HDPE.

The majority of a utility’s capital investment is underground. When planning for investment in the important component of your system, ALL factors should be considered. Energy Savings is one very important one that should be considered.

Subscribe to the Iron Strong Blog

Share on social media

  • Print this Article

Jon Melloan

I graduated from Eastern Kentucky University with a degree in Public Relations/ Marketing in 1992.   Prior to joining McWane Ductile, I held various positions with Smith Contractors, a medium sized contractor in Lawrenceburg, KY, from 1992-1999. Smith primarily bid municipal Water and Sewer utility work.   

I joined McWane Ductile in 2003 and have worked to build strong contractor and distributor relationships as a Sales Rep. for the Kentucky, Southern Indiana & Southwestern Ohio territories.

I was born and raised in Lawrenceburg, KY and I still live there with my wife, Christy, daughter Lillee (9), and son, Jon “Hanks” (8).   I love playing golf, boating on Lake Cumberland or Dale Hollow Lake and I also enjoy fishing and hunting.   

You can reach me by email at jon.melloan@mcwaneductile.com or connect with me on Lined In at https://www.linkedin.com/in/jon-melloan-494b9435/

  • Learning Center
  • Specifications
  • Submittal Sheets
  • Installation Guides
  • Downloadable Tip Sheets
  • Iron Strong Blog
  • Training Opportunities
  • Archived Catalogs
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Videos
  • Pocket Engineer
  • Blog
  • Categories
  • Environmental & Safety
  • Installation
  • Our Company
  • Products
  • Services
  • Technical

Careers

Apply or view job opportunities

Search Careers

McWane Pocket Engineer

McWane Pocket Engineer

The one tool you never want to be without

Learn More

Buy American

Your trusted provider of guaranteed American-made waterworks products.

Learn More

Recognized as a proud member

  • ISI Member
  • DIPRA Logo
  • American Water Works Association
  • Water and Sewer Distributors of American WASDA
  • National Association of Water Companies
  • Water Environment Federation WEF
  • Products|
  • Learning Center|
  • Sales & Support|
  • Corporate Responsibility|
  • About Us|
  • Communications|
  • Careers

McWane Corporate

  • About|
  • Our Businesses|
  • Responsibility|
  • Environment|
  • Safe Operations|
  • Communications|
  • Careers|
  • Multimedia Library
Learn about McWane’s Environmental Focus

© 2021 McWane Ductile. All rights reserved

Privacy Policy | California Privacy Notice | Terms & Conditions | California Transparency in Supply Chain Disclosure | Sitemap | Contact Us

  • Products
  • Product Catalog
  • Ductile Iron Pipe
  • Request Product Information
  • Learning Center
  • Specifications
  • Submittal Sheets
  • Installation Guides
  • Downloadable Tip Sheets
  • Iron Strong Blog
  • Training Opportunities
  • Archived Catalogs
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Videos
  • Pocket Engineer
  • Sales & Support
  • Sales Team
  • Distributors
  • Treatment Plant Sales
  • Customer Service
  • Sales Operations
  • Corporate Responsibility
  • Code of Conduct
  • Environment
    • Protecting the Environment
      • Our Environmental Legacy
      • Investments
      • Environmental Management System
      • ISO & State Certifications
      • Environmental Excellence
      • Pollution Prevention Challenge
    • Sustainability for Generations
      • Sustainable Products
      • Sustainable Operations
  • Health & Safety
    • Culture of Safety
    • EHS Policy
    • McWane EHS Program
    • Ergo Cup
    • ISN & Contractor Safety
    • EHS Awards
  • Community
    • McWane Commitment
    • Partnerships
    • Community Advisory Panel
    • Charitable Giving Guidelines
  • Awards
  • About Us
  • Company History
  • Executive Team
  • Locations
  • Associations
  • Publications
  • Contact Us
  • Communications
  • McWane News Articles
  • Press Releases
  • Media Contacts
  • Careers
  • Team Members